Let's start with the actors. Brad Pitt plays Aldo Raine, the drawling but dangerous Tennessee man with gallows scars (never explained in the film) who leads a team of Jews into Nazi occupied France to fight a guerrilla war. Tarantino may have made a daring move by making the film's (arguably) main character its greatest source of comic relief, but it works nonetheless. While I won't spoil its context, he speaks Italian at one point in the film and the results are uproarious. His number two is Donny Donowitz (Eli Roth) is a man as blunt and violent as the films which Roth himself has directed in the past. He, along with the remainder of the American cast, represents the desire for retribution which has circulated among many among the Jewish people since the beginning of the Holocaust. The results of their actions in this film, in an ambitious alternate history, were truly cathartic to me on a personal level, as it may well be for anyone whose relatives or friends were murdered by the evils of Nazi Germany.
Just...wow
I have, however, been dancing around naming the true driving star of this film, who in the end ties Raine's Basterds with Shoshanna's revenge story. This is the man who killed that young woman's family, an SS agent named Hans Landa (Christoph Waltz). Landa is a man who tiptoes on the edge of parody while maintaining a deep and penetrating menace. He never speaks without a smile, but through that smile is a mind which is calculating the best way to expose and destroy the enemies of his state. Playing a mindless and destructive Nazi is easy, but portraying the darkest side of the SS through such a pleasant facade is truly marvelous. I will be shocked if Waltz is not at least nominated for the Academy's best actor award.
A man with a pipe this ridiculous is always hiding something that is truly disturbing
In regard the direction, this is Tarantino's best work since Pulp Fiction. As expected, he stretches the normal boundaries of a 1940's time-piece through its homages to spaghetti-westerns, 1970's war films, and even Blaxploitation flicks. The soundtrack includes pieces which vary from orchestral movements to a David Bowie song, but none of it feels out of place within the context of this film. He also maintains a good pace all throughout the movie, though it is a pace that varies from the chillingly protracted conversation between Landa and a Frenchman who is harboring Jewish refugees to a shootout between a dozen people that is over within seconds. Finally, I should mention that for those who are curious he DID find a way to include Samuel L. Jackson, and the results are (in)glorious.
Go watch this film while its still in theaters, the experience won't quite be the same when its released on DVD, but I can guarantee that I'll still be at Wal-mart on that morning to pick up my copy.